info@cognitoitconsultancy.com
Mon–Fri · 9:00 am – 7:00 pm IST
Whitefield, Bangalore
Verified Shopify Partner
WhatsApp Support Icon
Recharge vs Bold Subscriptions
Recharge vs Bold Subscriptions
Subscription App Decision · Prices checked 14 November 2026

Recharge vs Bold.
The Subscription App Decision.

Two heavyweights, plus Shopify's own Subscriptions app. Each fits a different stage. This is a side-by-side comparison using prices and features from each vendor's own pages, checked 14 November 2026, with notes on UPI Autopay for India.

3-app pricing compare
Feature matrix with sources
UPI Autopay India
Migration paths
3 Apps at a Glance

Pricing & Sweet Spot.

Retention tools
Recharge
Customer portal and retention tools
Starter / Scale
$149-499
/ month + 1.25-1.5% + 20¢ per order
Cancellation prevention and failed-payment recovery
Bundles and tiered discounts (Scale plan)
Gifting (Scale plan)
No-code customer portal
Check gateway support for India (see below)
Analytics and automated workflows
Suits brands where subscriptions are a core revenue line
Lower entry price
Bold Subscriptions
Built for Shopify checkout
Launch / Grow / Scale
$24.99-74.99
/ month + 0.9-2% per order
Works with Shopify checkout
Lower entry price than Recharge
Prepaid subscriptions on every plan
Build-a-box + bundles
30-day free trial (transaction fees still apply)
Dunning for failed payments
Suits brands that want a lower entry price
Free from Shopify
Shopify Subscriptions
Shopify Subscriptions app
App price
$0
+ payment processing fees
Free app on the Shopify App Store
Native Shopify checkout
Weekly, monthly or yearly plans
Customer portal: skip, pause, cancel
Plan discounts: amount, percentage or buy X get Y
No dedicated churn tools listed
Suits stores starting with simple subscriptions
Feature Matrix

Side-by-Side Compared.

Feature
Recharge
Bold
Shopify-native
Monthly fee
From $149
From $24.99
Free
Transaction fee
1.25-1.5% + 20¢
0.9-2% by plan
None listed
Free trial
60 days (Starter)
30 days (monthly fee only)
Free app
Shopify checkout
Yes
Yes
Yes
Churn tools
Cancellation prevention, payment recovery
Dunning for failed payments
Skip, pause, cancel only
Bundles / build-a-box
Scale plan
Yes
Not listed
Prepaid subscriptions
Not listed
Yes, all plans
Not listed
Gift subscriptions
Scale plan
Not listed
Not listed
Customer portal
No-code portal
Not listed
Resume, skip, cancel, payment and address updates

Prices and features checked 14 November 2026 on Recharge pricing, Bold's help center, the Shopify App Store listing and the Shopify Help Center. "Not listed" means the pages we checked do not state it, so confirm with the vendor. Fees are in US dollars and change often.

India Specific

UPI Autopay for Subscriptions.

How UPI Autopay mandates work, and what to check before choosing an app.

India D2C Reality

How UPI Autopay works on Shopify subscriptions

First subscription order — customer signs UPI mandate (NPCI eMandate)
Subsequent renewals — auto-debit on schedule through your payment gateway
Supported frequencies depend on your gateway and merchant category, so check its documentation
Razorpay's docs list mandate creation up to ₹1,00,000, and debits without extra authentication up to ₹15,000 for most merchants (₹1,00,000 for BFSI merchants). Source
Customer can revoke mandate from their UPI app any time
Some renewals will fail (expired cards, low balance, revoked mandates), so retry and reminder flows matter
App Differences

Check gateway support first

Recharge: its help center lists Shopify Payments, Stripe, PayPal Express, Authorize.net and Adyen as payment processors, and does not list Razorpay. Confirm with Recharge before planning around it.
Bold: built for Shopify checkout, so it follows the gateways your store uses. Confirm UPI Autopay support with Bold.
Shopify-native: check Shopify's current documentation for UPI Autopay support in India.
Shopify Payments is not available in India, so Indian stores use a third-party gateway such as Razorpay, Cashfree or PayU.
We confirm gateway support with the app vendor during the audit, before you commit.
Who Should Pick Which

Use-Case Split.

Pick Recharge

Scale D2C subscription brand

Subscriptions are a core revenue line and you want bundles, tiered discounts and retention tools.

Subscriptions are a core revenue line
Retention tools matter for your category (food, beauty refills)
Need bundles, tiered discounts or gifting (Scale plan)
India: confirm gateway support with Recharge first
Budget for $149-499 a month plus 1.25-1.5% and 20¢ per order
Pick Bold

Mid-tier, Shopify-checkout-first brand

You want an app built for Shopify checkout and a lower entry price.

You want to start from $24.99 a month
Want to stay on Shopify checkout
Cost-sensitive: entry plan is $24.99 a month vs Recharge's $149 Starter
Simpler product set, fewer SKUs in subs
India: confirm UPI Autopay support with Bold first
Pick Shopify-Native

Just starting out / single-SKU sub

No app fee. Shopify checkout. Weekly, monthly or yearly plans. Enough for simple subscriptions.

A small number of active subscribers
Single-SKU repeat subscription (one product)
Don't need bundles or advanced retention tools yet
Want no app fee
Plan to migrate to Recharge / Bold at scale
FAQ

Subscription Questions

Need a migration plan? Book a 30-min call →

It depends on your plan and the tools you need. Recharge costs more (Starter $149 a month, Scale $499) and adds bundles, tiered discounts and gifting on the Scale plan. Bold starts at $24.99 a month and works with Shopify checkout. For simple subscriptions, Shopify's free Subscriptions app may be enough. For India, confirm which payment gateways each app supports before you decide. See our subscription setup guide.
Checked 14 November 2026. Recharge lists Starter at $149 a month plus 1.50% + 20¢ per transaction, Scale at $499 a month plus 1.25% + 20¢, and custom pricing above that. Bold Subscriptions lists Launch at $24.99 a month plus 2%, Grow at $49.99 plus 1% and Scale at $74.99 plus 0.9%, with a 30-day free trial that waives the monthly fee but not transaction fees. Shopify's Subscriptions app is free; payment processing fees still apply. Prices change, so check each vendor's pricing page.
We could not confirm it. Razorpay supports UPI Autopay, but we found nothing showing that Recharge or Bold support Razorpay UPI Autopay on Shopify. Recharge's help center lists Shopify Payments, Stripe, PayPal Express, Authorize.net and Adyen as payment processors, and Shopify Payments is not available in India. Ask each vendor which gateways and payment methods they support for Indian stores before you commit. We confirm this with the vendor during the audit.
Yes, subscriptions can be moved between apps. What has to carry over: subscriber identity, subscription product mapping, next billing date, subscription status, saved payment methods (shoppers may need to re-authorize with some gateways), discount codes and billing intervals. Shoppers should be told before the move. Timing and risk depend on your subscriber count and gateway, so we scope it in the audit.
Shopify's free Subscriptions app supports weekly, monthly or yearly plans, discounts, a customer portal where shoppers can skip, pause or cancel, and basic reporting. Its listing does not mention bundles, prepaid plans or dedicated churn tools. For simple recurring orders it can be enough. If you need bundles, prepaid plans or retention tools, compare Recharge and Bold.
Free Subscription Audit

Pick & Configure The Right App.

30-minute call. We review your GMV, subscription product set, churn rate, India payment needs — and recommend the right app. Setup or migration plan within 2 working days, fixed-price. Pair with our subscription setup service for end-to-end build.

Start Today

Your High-Converting Shopify Store,
Built in 2–3 Weeks

Fixed price · 2–3 week delivery · 30 days post-launch support · Any timezone

🇮🇳 India · 🇺🇸 USA · 🇬🇧 UK · 🇦🇪 UAE · 🇨🇦 Canada · 🇦🇺 Australia · 🇸🇬 Singapore
100+
Stores built
2–3 wk
Standard launch
Fixed
Price, in writing
30 days
Post-launch support
2 days
Proposal & audit (working days)
© 2026 Cognito IT Consultancy. All rights reserved. Whitefield, Bangalore, India.
🇮🇳 🇺🇸 🇬🇧 🇦🇪 🇨🇦 🇦🇺 🇸🇬